Take Control of Backing Up Your Mac: The Online Appendixes Info about dozens of Mac backup products and services!

Welcome! If you want to compare features in Mac backup products and services, you’re in the right place. The content here is free to all, but it is associated with a commercial book, written by Joe Kissell and published by alt concepts inc. The book helps you figure out your best strategy for making backups in macOS, and then it covers all the details of set up, testing, maintenance, and restoration.

There are dozens of apps and services you can use to back up a Mac, and the list is constantly changing. In Take Control of Backing Up Your Mac, I go into great detail about developing a backup strategy, selecting media, setting up a backup system, and recovering data when the need arises. I also discuss the criteria you should consider when choosing backup software. But rather than list them all in the book, I’ve moved most of the details to this online appendix for easier updating. This appendix covers only consumer apps (not enterprise-oriented software or command-line tools).

Although I’ve tried to be thorough and accurate, I haven’t listed every single feature, nor do I rate or rank backup apps. However, I do make specific recommendations in Take Control of Backing Up Your Mac. I will update this page from time to time as features and prices change, and as errors are discovered.

On this tab:

On other tabs:

The products in this table enable you to back up data from your Mac to the cloud, and except as noted, they automatically maintain multiple versions of each file. Most of these are services that include their own Mac software, but a few (including Arq, CloudBerry Backup, Duplicati, Duplicacy, and Jungle Disk) are apps that work with storage space you buy separately, such as Amazon S3. In any case, you’ll be paying monthly for cloud storage. (Some of these products also appear on the Backup Software tab.)

Last updated: January 22, 2019

Online Backup Products

Product Name Version Price Versioning macOS
Compatibility
Available for
Other Platforms
Online Storage Syncing Sharing File Retention Delta
Encoding
Deduplication Compression Encryption Restore
Feature
Seeding Physical
Restore Media
Scheduling Change
Detection
Metadata
Support
Notes
Acronis True Image 2019 (23.4) $49.99 for software only; subscriptions including cloud storage start at $49.99 per year (for 250 GB). Up to 20 previous versions 10.8–10.14 Windows Proprietary Windows only Windows only Indefinite Yes Yes Yes No No Min. once/hour Real-time tracking Not tested Creates images that can be restored to a bootable state, as well as a recovery drive, but not bootable duplicates as such. Can store full images in the cloud, bandwidth and data caps permitting.
Arq 5.14.3 $49.99; cloud storage extra (Arq's own cloud backup service costs $5.99 per month for 1 TB) Yes 10.5–10.14 Windows Arq Cloud Backup; Amazon Cloud Drive, S3, and Glacier; Backblaze B2; Dropbox; DreamObjects; Google Drive and Google Cloud Storage; OneDrive; Wasabi; SFTP; local, network, and NAS folders No No Indefinite Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Min. once/hour A+
Backblaze 6.0.0.292 $5 per month or $50 per year for unlimited storage of data from a single computer Unlimited 10.6–10.14 Windows, iOS Proprietary No No 4 weeks Yes Yes Yes Yes; personal key available See note. No Yes Continuous (see note), once per day, or manual Dynamic C To restore data, you can download a single file or a ZIP archive of multiple files, or request a USB flash drive or hard drive with your data. In all cases, though, you must manually put files back where they belong. "Continuous" backups may involve delays of 2 hours or more after a file is added or changed before it is backed up.
Carbonite Safe Backup 1.1.22 & 2.7.5 $71.99 per year for unlimited storage of files from a single computer; business plans also available NO (Windows only) 10.6–10.14 Windows, Android, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes 30 days Yes No Yes Yes, but no personal key option for Mac users. Yes No No (Windows only) Min. once/day Dynamic C
CloudBacko 3.5.0.1 Home version: free; Lite version: $25; Pro version: $99; cloud storage extra Yes 10.7.3–10.13 Windows, Linux Amazon Cloud Drive, Amazon S3, Dropbox, FTP/SFTP, Google Cloud Storage, Google Drive, Microsoft Azure, OneDrive, OpenStack, Rackspace Cloud Files, others No No See note. Yes Yes Yes Yes Only with Amazon S3 No Min. once/day. See note. Not tested. Can spread backup data across multiple cloud destinations. Home and Lite versions have limited control over retention; Pro version offers complete control. Home version has no scheduling (manual backups only). Uses (and includes) Java, requires the user to install Java from Oracle, and has a pretty ugly, un-Mac-like user interface.
CloudBerry Backup 2.7 Free version with limited features; $29.99 Pro version Yes 10.8-10.14 Windows, Linux Amazon S3, Amazon Glacier, Backblaze B2, Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud Storage, Wasabi, others No No Unlimited Pro version only Pro version only Yes No No Min. once/minute Not tested.
coolBackup 5.73 Plans start at $4.99 per user per month for 100+ GB of storage. Yes ? Windows, Linux, Android, iOS Proprietary (FTP, SFTP, SSL/TSL available with paid plans) Yes Yes Indefinite (user preference) Paid plans only Yes Yes Min. once/hour C Mac app hasn’t been updated since 2012.
DollyDrive 4.57 Prices start at $5/month for 500 GB. Yes 10.5–10.14 iOS Proprietary Yes Yes Indefinite Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Syncing (Dolly Space) is continuous; for backups, min. once/hour Dynamic Not tested
Duplicacy 2.1.2 computer and $10 for each additional Yes ? Windows, Linux Amazon S3, Backblaze B2, Dropbox, Google Drive, Google Cloud Storage, OneDrive, Wasabi, SFTP, others No No Indefinite Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Not tested.
Duplicati 2.0.4.5 Free (donations requested; online storage extra) Yes ? Windows, Linux Amazon Drive, Box, FTP, Google Drive, OneDrive, Rackspace, S3, SFTP, SSH, WebDAV, others Indefinite Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Min. once/second Dynamic Not tested
ElephantDrive 5.8.16 2 GB free; prices range from $9.95/month (for 1 TB) to $39.95/month (for 2 TB). Yes ? Windows, Linux, iOS, Android Proprietary Yes Yes Indefinite Yes Automatic on file change Dynamic Not tested Uses a Java app, and requires the user to install Java from Oracle.
IBackup for Mac 3.3.1.1 Prices start at $9.95 per month for 500 GB. 10 versions of each file 10.9–10.14 Windows Proprietary Yes 30 days Yes Yes Yes Yes No Automatic on file change or min. once/hour Not tested
IDrive Online Backup 3.5.4.0 5 GB free; prices start at $69.50/year for 2 TB (discount available for first year only). 10 versions of each file 10.5–10.13 Windows Proprietary Yes Yes Indefinite (See note.) Yes No Yes Yes; personal key available Yes Yes Yes Continous or min. once/hour Dynamic C User-specified pruning is optional.
JustCloud Prices start at $182.64 per two years for 75 GB of storage. 7 versions of each file 10.5+ Windows, iOS, Android, Blackberry, Kindle Fire Proprietary Yes Yes Indefinite Yes Yes Yes, but no personal key option. Yes No No Not tested
Jungle Disk 3.3.0.6 Starts at $4 per user per month; 10 GB free storage; additional S3 storage extra Yes 10.9–10.14 Windows, Linux, iOS Amazon S3, Rackspace Yes See note. Indefinite (user preference) Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Automatic on file change or min. once/5 minutes Dynamic A+ Sharing among within an organization is available with Workgroup Edition.
Livedrive Backup Prices start at $8/month for unlimited storage for one computer. 30 versions 10.10-10.14 Windows, Android, iOS Proprietary No No 30 days Yes, but no personal key option. Not tested
Norton Online Backup
(part of Norton Security
Premium)
8.1.2f27 $54.99 (for the first year; then prices increase) for 25 GB of storage from up to 10 devices Yes 10.12–10.14 Windows Proprietary 90 days Yes Yes Yes Yes No No ? Not tested
SOS Online Backup 3.11 Prices start at $4.99/month for 50 GB of storage. Unlimited 10.8–10.14 iOS, Windows, Linux, Android Proprietary No Yes Indefinite Yes Yes Yes Yes; personal key available Yes No Yes Continuous or min. once/hour Scanning Not tested
Zoolz Home Prices start at $39.95/year for 1 TB. Unlimited ? iOS, Windows, Android Proprietary No Yes Indefinite Yes Yes Yes Yes; personal key available Yes Yes No Min. once/12 hours Not tested Includes local storage option, but only in addition to (not instead of) cloud backup.

Online Storage and Syncing Services

This table lists services designed primarily to sync files from your Mac to the cloud, and from there, with your other devices. Most of these also let you share files and folders with other people. Because in most cases they automatically store versioned backups of your files, too, they provide a basic backup function. But they aren’t designed to back up all your data or to restore it as conveniently as a true backup app, and their prices are often far higher than the backup services listed in the other table on this page. (Some of these products also appear on the Backup Software tab.)

Product Name Version Price Versioning macOS
Compatibility
Available for
Other Platforms
Online Storage Syncing Sharing File Retention Delta
Encoding
Deduplication Compression Encryption Seeding Physical
Restore Media
Scheduling Change
Detection
Metadata
Support
Notes
Amazon Cloud Drive 5.7.10 (uses Amazon Photos app) $59.99/year for 1 TB No 10.7–10.14 Windows, Android, iOS Proprietary No Yes Indefinite (?) for deleted files Yes No No Not tested
Box Drive 10 GB free; $10/month for 100 GB Yes 10.9-10.14 Windows, Android, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes Indefinite Yes No No Automatic on file change or manual Dynamic Not tested
CloudMe 1.11.4 3 GB free; paid plans start at €1 per month for 10 GB. Yes 10.6–10.14 Windows, Linux, Android, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes Not tested
Degoo Up to 100 GB free (see note); pricing starts at $9.99 per month for 2 TB. Yes iOS, Android, Windows Proprietary Yes Automatic on file change Dynamic Not tested. Free users must invite 10 friends to unlock extra storage space and access the Mac client.
Dropbox 65.3.174 2 GB free; $9.99/month for 1 TB. Yes 10.10–10.14 Windows, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes 30 days (see note). Yes Yes No Yes No No Automatic on file change Dynamic C Stores old/deleted files for up to 30 days unless you buy the optional ($39 per year) Extended Version History option, which provides 1-year retention.
Google Drive 3.43 15 GB free; pricing starts at $1.99/month for 100 GB Yes 10.10–10.14 Windows, Android, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes 30 days or 100 revisions (See note.) No No No No No Automatic on file change Dynamic Not tested You can disable automatic deletion for individual items.
Livedrive Briefcase Prices start at $16/month for 2 TB of storage. 30 versions of each file 10.10-10.14 Windows Proprietary Yes Yes 30 days Yes Yes Yes No Automatic on file change Dynamic Not tested
MEGA Pricing starts at €4.99 per month for 200 GB. Yes ? Windows, Android, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes No No Yes No No Automatic on file change Dynamic Not tested
Microsoft OneDrive 5 GB free; pricing starts at $1.99/month for 50 GB. Yes 10.10–10.14 Windows, Android, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes Not stated No No No No No Automatic on file change Dynamic Not tested
pCloud Prices start at $3.99/month for 500 GB. Yes 10.10–10.14 Windows, Linux, Android, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes 30 days (extended revision history available) Yes No No Automatic on file change Dynamic Not tested
SpiderOak One 7.3.0 Prices start at $6 per month for 150 GB. Yes 10.9–10.14 Windows, Linux Proprietary, FTP, SFTP Yes Yes Indefinite Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Automatic on file change or min. once/minute Dynamic C
Strongspace 6.2.1 Starts at $10 per month per user for 1 TB. Yes Windows, Linux SFTP, rsync No Yes Yes, via rsync No No Automatic (within 10 minutes) on file change Dynamic Not tested
SugarSync 3.10.3 30-day, 5 GB free trial; prices start at $7.49/month for 100 GB. Yes (See note.) 10.8–10.14 Windows, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes Limited (See note.) Yes Yes Yes No No Automatic on file change Dynamic C Can sync between Macs (and PCs and handhelds). Keeps up to five previous versions of files indefinitely.
Sync.com $8 per month for 2 TB. Yes ? Windows, Android, Linux, iOS Proprietary You think? :-) Yes Unlimited (paid plans) Yes No No Not tested
Tresorit Personal 14-day free trial; $30 per month for 2 TB. Yes ? Windows, Android, Linux, iOS Proprietary Yes Yes Unlimited Yes No No Not tested

Photo Sharing Services

Cloud services such as Dropbox and iCloud let you store and share photos along with the rest of your files (up to the limits of your paid plan). In addition, numerous companies provide extensive (or, in some cases, unlimited) stand-alone storage for your digital photos and videos, along with complete control over which ones are shared and with whom, sometimes for as little as zero dollars! Here are some examples of popular photo sharing sites:

  • Amazon Photos: A bonus benefit of a $119-per-year Amazon Prime membership, Prime Photos lets you store unlimited photos, and 5 GB of videos and other files, on Amazon’s servers. You can upgrade to a 1 TB Amazon storage plan for $59.99 per year, which lets you store any files.
  • DPhoto: Standard accounts cost $60 per year for up to 500 GB of storage, with individual photos up to 100 MB. Premium accounts (at $120 per year) offer 1 TB of storage along with several additional features.
  • Flickr: Every user gets free storage for 1,000 photos. Pro accounts ($5.99 per month) offer unlimited storage.
  • Fotki: Free accounts give you 5 GB of space. Premium accounts (which start at $1.53 per month, billed annually) provide 100 GB or more of storage plus advanced features.
  • Shutterfly: Membership is free; storage is unlimited.
  • SmugMug: Membership levels are Basic ($5.99 per month or $47.88 per year), Power ($8.99 per month or $71.88 per year), Portfolio ($23.99 per month or $179.88 per year), and Pro ($41.99 per month or $359.88 per year). All the levels include unlimited storage; higher levels provide more customization options and higher monthly traffic quotas.
  • Snapfish: This service provides free, unlimited storage as long as you make at least one purchase (of any amount) annually.

Except for Fotki, all these services offer Mac-compatible photo upload software; iPhoto has built-in connections to Flickr and Facebook. Fotki offers uploading via email, and Fotki Premium members can upload photos via FTP.

Feature Explanations for This Tab

Versioning: A versioned backup starts with a complete copy of all the files in one or more folders. The next time the backup runs, your backup software performs an incremental update, which means it copies only those files that are new (or newly modified) since the last backup. If the software supports versioning, it means the backup program adds the new or changed data to the backup without overwriting the files already there. That way, you can retrieve many different versions of a given file, and if you delete it on your hard disk, you can still find it in your backup.

macOS Compatibility: This column lists the versions of macOS the program supports, as reported by the developer. A “?” in this column simply means the developer hasn’t specifically stated compatibility (beyond the version listed, if any).

Available for Other Platforms: A number of these Mac backup programs also come in versions for Windows and/or Linux. If you need to back up several computers running different operating systems, you may appreciate the convenience and familiarity of a single tool that works on all of them. Usually, though not always, if you create versioned backups with a multi-platform program, you can open and restore your files from another platform than the one you used to back them up. On the other hand, note that a few of the cross-platform programs have truly hideous user interfaces that were either written in Java without any consideration for the Mac aesthetic, or very badly ported from another operating system. Some cloud backup services also offer mobile apps that let you access your backed-up data from a tablet or smartphone.

Online Storage: Nearly all online backup services use their own proprietary transfer systems that require special software, but some of them also let you access their storage via common protocols such as SFTP. In addition, some of the software listed here can work with online services that use a variety of protocols.

Syncing: Some online backup and storage services can also sync selected files and folders among your various devices via the cloud. If so, you’ll see a Yes in this column.

Sharing: Once you’ve stored a file or folder in the cloud somewhere, you may want to give someone else access to it. Although services differ widely in how they implement sharing, as long as there’s some way to do it, you’ll see a Yes here.

File Retention: When you’re backing up to a destination with a fixed capacity (a local hard drive or an online service that puts an upper limit on how much you can store), it’s nice to have the option to automatically remove older versions of files, and deleted files, from your backups to save space. However, you may want to make that decision yourself—and if your online storage is unlimited, you may prefer never to delete anything. Therefore, in the File Retention column, I’ve indicated (where known) the length of time the provider will hang onto old versions and deleted files. (In some cases, retention is based on number of file versions rather than time.)

Delta Encoding: Historically, most backup software has performed versioned backups on a file-by-file basis. In other words, if just 10 bytes of a 10 GB file change, that marks the file as modified, and the whole file must be copied on the next backup run. Some software, however, can copy only the individual bytes that have changed since the last backup, while other software copies slightly larger units called blocks. Copying just the delta—that is, the differences between the file at time A and the file at time B—is known as delta encoding, though you may see other terms, such as “sub-file,” “byte-level,” and “block-level” incremental updates. The advantage of such an approach is that backups go much faster after the initial run and take up far less storage space; this is particularly important when backing up over the Internet. The disadvantage is that restoring a file requires the backup software to reconstruct it by putting together the pieces from all its incremental backups. If even a single one of those incremental bits were to become damaged or lost, you might be unable to restore the file.

Deduplication: Simply put, deduplication is the process of ensuring that data stored on your backup destination volume isn’t duplicated—which reduces the amount of storage space required (sometimes dramatically), and can also speed up backups considerably. For example, if you have two copies of a file on your disk, a program that features deduplication will store only one copy on your backup media, along with a pointer to the other one (so that the file can be restored to either location with equal ease). In most cases, deduplication is done on a block-by-block or even byte-by-byte basis, so that when files are quite similar, only one complete copy of the file is stored, along with the differences found in the other version(s) so that any of them can be reconstructed. In other cases, it’s done at the file level—two identical files won’t be duplicated, but if the files are only 99 percent the same, they will be. Some implementations of deduplication can compare data from multiple computers, while others can deduplicate data only from a single source.

Compression: When a backup application compresses your files, they take up less room on your storage media—usually a good thing, as that reduces your costs and lets you store backups for longer periods of time before having to reuse your media. Compression is even more important when data is traveling over the Internet, because compressed data takes less time to send, and online storage costs are often much higher than the cost of local media. On the other hand, compressing files taxes your computer’s CPU, RAM, and disk, and having compressed files may add an extra complication when it comes time to restore data.

Encryption: As long as your backup media is under your physical control, encryption isn’t especially important. But if you store backup media offsite in any fashion, or if anyone else (a thief, say, or a nosy coworker) can get access to your backups, you might prefer that they not be able to see all your data. Almost all online backup and storage providers offer some form of encryption, but most of them use an encryption key that they (the providers) hold, meaning they can access any of your encrypted files. Providers with better security let you use a personal key that only you know, and that is stored only on your own computers—not on the server.

Restore Feature: A restore feature simply means that, with a button click or menu command, you can instruct your backup program to return files that you previously backed up to their original location (or, if you prefer, another location). Quite a few programs expect you to simply switch the “source” and “destination” and, essentially, redo your backup. A restore feature is most important with backup programs that store multiple versions of your files, because otherwise, sifting through a lot of different file versions by hand is going to be a real pain.

Seeding: When backing up your data online, the initial backup (which could be tens or hundreds of gigabytes) is always the most painful. Even with a fast broadband connection, it could take weeks. Seeding lets you perform an initial backup to a local hard drive and send that drive to the cloud provider, which then loads your data onto its servers. Thereafter, you need only copy new or changed data, which is much quicker. Most companies charge an extra fee for seeding.

Physical Restore Media: This is the opposite of seeding—if the need arises to restore a large quantity of data, the storage provider can copy your data onto physical media (a hard drive or DVD) and send it to you (for a fee, of course). The benefit is that restoration is much faster this way than downloading all your data.

Scheduling: Traditionally, most backup programs have used a fixed schedule: you set a time (once a day, twice a week, or whatever—maybe in the middle of the night) and the software does its thing only at that time. For software that uses a fixed schedule, this column lists the most frequent option available (such as once per hour or once per day). Increasingly, though, backup programs offer some form of automatic operation (either by default or as an option), such as backing up files continuously, as they change, or running in the background every hour. In general, if a program can run once an hour or more frequently and it dynamically detects changed files (see just ahead) so that it needn’t do a full scan with each run, it is effectively schedule-free. On the other hand, some backup programs don’t support any kind of scheduling—they run only when you activate them manually. The majority of online backup and storage services can copy your data to the cloud immediately when it changes (see the next point).

Change Detection: Some programs can detect file changes in real time, either by using macOS’s FSEvents (file system events) framework or by running in the background and employing proprietary methods to watch for changes. In whatever form, dynamic change detection reduces or eliminates the need for a time-consuming scan each time your backups run and, in some cases, enables continuous, real-time backups as your files change. (Even so, occasional full scans may be necessary.)

Metadata Support: Even though a file may appear to copy correctly, some important information about the file may be missing or incorrect—things like ownership, permissions, modification date, Finder flags, access control lists, and many others (collectively known as “metadata”). Theoretically, backup software should copy every piece of metadata perfectly, though in practice, many types of metadata are so insignificant or seldom used that no harm is done if they’re missing in your backups. Faithful copying of metadata is most crucial when making a bootable duplicate.

I used a tool called Backup Bouncer to test metadata support for as many of these programs as I could. Backup Bouncer checks a great many attributes, but it divides its results according to how significant the developer feels each one is: “critical,” “important,” and “other.” I’ve used the Backup Bouncer results to assign a “grade,” as follows:

  • A+: The software passes ALL of Backup Bouncer’s tests perfectly.
  • A: All “critical” and “important” attributes are copied correctly.
  • B: All “critical” attributes are copied correctly, but at least one “important” attribute is not copied correctly.
  • C: At least one “critical” attribute is not copied correctly.

Although metadata is in some cases very important, I urge you to take these test results (especially the “C” grade) with a grain of salt, for two reasons. First, because of the way Backup Bouncer groups its results, a fairly insignificant problem can sometimes result in a failed test in a “critical” category. And second, depending on the way a given backup program is designed and used, it may be irrelevant that certain attributes (such as file ownership) aren’t always copied correctly. Also, the difference between an “A+” and an “A” is effectively meaningless. So basically: don’t freak if your favorite program gets a less-than-perfect score—but do consider contacting its developer to suggest that they look into using Backup Bouncer to improve its metadata support in the future.

Where you see “Not tested” in this column, it means I haven’t taken the time to run the test—it’s time-consuming and not always worth the effort. “Unable to test” could mean any of several things: the software may not be compatible with the version of macOS on my test machine; it may be designed in such a way that it can’t work with Backup Bouncer’s test suite; or I may not have had access to a version of the program suitable for testing.

© Copyright 2019 alt concepts inc. All Rights Reserved.